This is one somewhat strange but
vastly entertaining movie about the life and work of comic book
cult writer Harvey Pekar and his underground comic named "American
Splendor". The movie doesn't just star Paul Giamatti in
the main role of Pekar, but Harvey Pekar himself narrates the film
and also has scenes playing his real self, talking not only about
his life but even about this same movie being made about his life.
Sounds strange? All I can say is this vastly original
stylish film works. Anybody who enjoyed the film Crumb about
that comic book genius will like this one as well. It
actually turns out that Pekar and Crumb were friends with Crumb
doing much of the sketch work of Pekar's stories for American
Splendor. Even some of the movie is done in animation.
Pekar works as a file clerk in a hospital and after meeting comic
book creator R. Crumb, gets the idea of creating a comic book
about his ordinary life. Crumb thinks his stories and
narratives so good that he offers to illustrate the frames. Pekar
is a guy with low self-esteem, has loud outbursts when he loses
his temper, and who has an obsessive/compulsive personality.
Sometime after his latest wife leaves him, Pekar meets Joyce
(played marvelously by Hope Davis) and somehow these two troubled
individuals fall in love and get married. The film deals mostly
with their marriage, Pekar's bout with cancer, and his attempts to
promote and sell his comic book. Pekar actually becomes a
cult guest on the David Letterman show and the film contains
actually footage of some of his appearances. We also meet
Pekar's very weird friend Toby who one day decides to drive
several hundred miles to see the movie Revenge of the Nerds
because he thinks it is an actual calling to all the nerdy people
like himself out there in the world.
The style of this film is something I have never seen in movies
before. It contains actors playing real people as well as
the real people themselves. The film mixes in animation of
some of these people as well, and the story bounces seamlessly
back and forward between all these scenarios. There is also a lot
of good music from the 70's and 80's. The films takes it's
time developing and establishing this Pekar character so that the
audience learns exactly what kind of man he is.
There is some excellent acting done in this film. Giamatti
really takes over this role as this compulsive and at times lonely
file clerk/comic book writer. All the mannerisms and facial
expressions that Giamatti displays as Pekar are right on the mark
and you just have to think that this is the real Pekar, even
though Giamatti and the real Pekar don't look that much alike.
Giamatti really puts on an entertaining show playing this
character and it's hard to take your eyes off of him when he is on
screen. Hope Davis is just perfect as his strange but
supportive wife who seems to spend most of her time sleeping or
searching for something meaningful to do with her life. Judah
Friedlander as the very strange and nerdy Toby could be seen as a
totally unreal and over-the-top character if you didn't find out
in the film that this is exactly how the real Toby acts.
So here is another small 2003 film that that I can highly
recommend. This would be a great movie to see as a double
feature with the movie Crumb. Both films are fascinating and
interesting by revealing how these neurotic and strange people
become comic book geniuses. It would not surprise me in the
least if both Giamatti and Davis get Academy Award nominations for
their roles in this film.