Popkorn Junkie

MOVIE REVIEW FOR Maid in Manhattan
Popkorn Junkie Home | Archive | About Us | Junkieville | Buzz-Links | Reviewers

Buy Maid in Manhattan Poster

Buy Maid in Manhattan Poster

Note: This film has a PG-13 rating

Junkie Rating:

This film received 1 1/2 pops out of 4 pops.This film received 1 1/2 pops out of 4 pops.This film received 1 1/2 pops out of 4 pops.This film received 1 1/2 pops out of 4 pops.

 

Cast and Credits

Wayne Wang (Director)
Jennifer Lopez (Marisa Ventura) 
Ralph Fiennes (Christopher Marshall)
Thomas Michael Sullivan (Papparazzi) 
Tyler Posey (Ty Ventura) 
Marissa Matrone (Stephanie Kehoe) 
Natasha Richardson (Caroline Sincaire) 
Chris Eigeman (John Bextram) 
Stanley Tucci (Jerry Siegel) 


Like the movie?  Maybe you'll like...

Buy Maid in Manhattan soundtrack
Buy Maid in Manhattan soundtrack

Buy Maid in Manhattan on DVD

Buy Maid in Manhattan on DVD

 

 
      I really loved this movie!  It's a sweet, heartfelt and believable Cinderella-like love story that will surely delight you. 

     Jennifer Lopez plays Marisa, a working-class maid in a posh Manhattan hotel.  Among the list of distinguished guests at the hotel is assemblyman, and candidate for governor, Chris Marshall (Ralph Fiennes).  One day Marisa brings her son to work and he runs amok.  In the elevator, he bumps into Chris who's about to walk his dog.  The son rushes to the room where his mother is cleaning to ask her if he can tag along with Chris.  When Chris and the son enter the room, Marisa walks out in a fancy dress, which belongs to one of the hotel's wealthy guests, Caroline Lane (Natasha Richardson).

     Marisa decides to tag along with both of them as they walk through Central Park.  Chris mistakes Marisa for Caroline, but she goes along with the lie and he ends up asking her to a ball.  Now, Marisa must keep trying to hide the fact that she's a maid, which is pretty difficult since a Paparazzi photo of her and Chris is on the front page of the paper and she is now assistant manager at the hotel.  

     "Maid in Manhattan" is not the usual dopey romantic comedy.  Yes, it's sentimental.  Yes, it has a happy ending.  But the ending made me smile, rather than cringe and sarcastically blurt out, "Jesus Christ, I didn't see that coming."  As a matter of fact, I was smiling throughout most of the film.  Its intention is to be a fluffy feel-good movie and it definitely made me feel good. 

     But it was only the film's charm that drew me in.  I also felt the love story was believable.  The way the usual formula would go is Ralph Fiennes' character is a tight-fisted politician and he meets a normal, everyday woman who loosens him up and his personality suddenly does a 360.  Instead, Fiennes is likeable and charming throughout.  I know that a down-to-earth politician is hard to find, and totally goes against stereotype, but I'm sure there are some of them out there.  Anyway, it feels convincing when he insists on chasing after Lopez's character, and it doesn't feel like a cheap Hollywood plot device. 

     The movie is a good change of pace for Ralph Fiennes, whose last role was an introverted serial killer in "Red Dragon".  He surely has what it takes to be a romantic lead, and him and Jennifer Lopez totally light up the screen.  Stanley Tucci plays Fiennes' uptight advisor, a role he's way too good at. 

     The story should contain no surprises, but I didn't mind.  As I mentioned, the characters are credible and the performances make them even more credible.  I enjoyed the subplot between Fiennes and Lopez's son, in which he tries to help the little man through his stage fright, a problem he's also dealing with.  That's another thing that made this movie work.  It has a great human element. 

     I left the theater feeling great.  Maybe I should call it a feel-great movie.  Is a good date movie?  Of course!  But I'm sure most guys will pretend they hated it, while they're heads are turned to the side as they discreetly wipe the tears off the sides of their eyes. 


     --
Matt ( 3 pops out of 4 pops ) 

 

Talk about this film with other Popkorn Junkies

 

Other Junkie's opinions.....

      Billy Ray ( 1/2 out of 4 pops )

     All the bad movies in the house say HO!  Why isn't "Maid for Manhattan" saying HO?  The only reason I saw this flick is because the original romantic comedy I wanted to see - "Two Weeks Notice" - was sold out.  Can you believe that - sold out!  The horror of it all.  So, being in that whole 'dating scenario', the person I was with opted to see this loathsome drag instead.  I mean, other than "The Cell", I have never liked Jennifer Lopez as an actress.  Ralph Fiennes is one of my favorites, but I just kept seeing that shyte-eating grin of his in this film and felt like I needed to take a shower.  This is every other romance from the 1950's combined together and shat out all over a modern day pop star and the guy who shot all the Jews in "Schindler's List".  The only bright spot in the whole dismal thing was Stanley Tucci (which is the only reason why I am even considering giving it a half of a pop), but not even Phil Hartman returned from the dead could have saved this picture.  So, essentially, I hated this film and give it a TERRIBLE recommendation.  Alas, all of you romantic comedy freaks out there will probably love it.  My final plea, however, is that you instead see "Two Weeks Notice".  I have yet to see it and already know it will be much better.  Hugh Grant can make THAT much of a difference.  Wait - maybe you shouldn't go out and see it.  The more people who go and see it, the more likely it will be sold out, forcing me to instead watch "The Hot Chick" again and drop rat poison in my soft drink to escape the pain of it all (NOTE:  for the funniest flick involving rat poison, rent "9 to 5", starring Lily Tomlin, Jane Fonda, Dolly Parton, and Dabney Coleman.  It is hilarious).