|
"The
Hours" has one of the most impressive casts of fine actors as
well as a large number of interesting characters that a film has had
in recent memory. So why did I find myself not overly
impressed with this film after it was over? I'll try to
explain this below. I always hate to criticize or not give a
film like this a more positive review because it certainly tries
hard to be a great literary work. This is an intelligent film
and interesting to watch, even though I left the theatre somewhat
disappointed overall.
The
story centers on three women living in three different generations
whose lives are connected in different ways to each other. We
are first introduced to Virginia Woolf, played by an unrecognizable
Nicole Kidman. She is obviously a deeply emotionally troubled
writer who is beginning to write one of her great novels called Mrs.
Dalloway. Next there is Laura Brown, played by Julianne Moore,
who seems to have the ideal life in the fifties with the perfect
husband, the perfect house, and the perfect child. However, we
soon find out that she is not only a very depressed and lonely
individual, but also a woman who seems to be questioning her own
sexuality. Then there is the modern day Clarissa Vaughan
played by Meryl Streep. Clarissa is a bisexual woman living
with another woman but whose life seems to be centered on taking
care of a man dying of aids played by the always terrific Ed Harris.
The
three main women are thematically linked by different threads which
I won't discuss here in order to not give away any of the plot.
However, suffice to say that it is Woolf's novel Mrs. Dalloway which
is the central piece that bonds the three stories together.
The film also deals with suicide and it is heavily filled with gay
and lesbian themes. As the story moves along to the end, the
basic plotline deals with all these characters trying to cope with
their internal demons.
As I stated earlier, the most
impressive thing about this film is the superb acting. Kidman,
Moore, and Streep all give their usual terrific and moving
performances. And Ed Harris is not to be overlooked for his
brave and magnificent portrayal of a guy dying of aids and not
really living anymore. I also want to give praise to many of
the other actors in smaller parts such as Toni Collette, Allison
Janney, and Jeff Daniels who all add effective characters to the
story. The narrative of the film is complex as it moves
back and forth seamlessly between the various stories. The
direction here is very good as the director is able to effortlessly
go back and forth between the stories being told during different
times and at different places.
So,
I gotta ask myself why I didn't like this film as much as I thought
I should. The biggest problem with this movie is that while it
has very complex material and is very intelligent, it just didn't
have the emotional connection that is not only required of a film
like this, it demands it. While the characters were all very
complex and interesting, this film needs the audience to bond with
at least one of them, if not most of them. And that just
didn't happen for me. I felt bored at times watching this film
and left the theatre thinking that there needed to be more to this
film, especially on an emotional level.
So,
this is a hard film for me to judge. Maybe if I had read
Woolf's Mrs Dalloway, I would have had a better appreciation for the
characters and a more positive reaction to this film. This one
easily gets a top rating for the acting, the story and the
direction, but it gets low marks for the lack emotional impact to
get the audience to care and bond with these three characters.
-- Mike (
2 1/2 out of 4 pops )
Talk
about this film with other Popkorn Junkies |
|
Other Junkie's
opinions.....
Billy Ray ( 2 1/2 out of 4 pops )
I couldn't help but be slightly disappointed with "The Hours", the new critically acclaimed film that racked up on Golden Globe night and seems poised to do the same come Oscar night. I guess I was expecting something extraordinary--a film of monumental power, but was instead dealt an emotional melodrama that really didn't tie itself together as well as I had hoped. Sure, each and every performance is powerful and pitch perfect, but I just felt a little cheated. We never really know why Julianne Moore and Meryl Streep are so damn unhappy. They have loving partners, wonderful children--but still sulk around the screen and seem poised on suicide. Why are they so unhappy? It seemed to me they really had no good reason. The only person who had a reason for being down in the dumps was Nicole Kidman, as Virginia Woolf--but she had mental issues. Director Stephen Daldry tried for something I don't think he really achieved. The movie seemed like it only lasted ninety minutes, and I am a firm believer than ninety minutes is not enough time to tell a story of this magnitude (I know, the running time was actually around an hour and forty-five, but that is still too short). I guess I just expected and needed more.
|